In a jaw-dropping twist that has fans buzzing, Emmerdale viewers are speculating that Robert Sugden could have another son, and this child might already be living in the village. Following Robert’s return to the village after a six-year absence, all eyes are on the potential for a big family revelation that could shake up the Dales once again.

Robert’s Dramatic Return and Theories About His Secret Son

Robert Sugden, played by Ryan Hawley, made a dramatic return to Emmerdale last week after spending six years in prison for the death of Lee Posner, who sexually assaulted his sister, Victoria Sugden. Robert’s prison sentence initially lasted 14 years, but he was granted an early release after successfully appealing his sentence. His return to the village wasn’t without its drama—Robert, who had been absent from the show since 2018, came back with a mission to stop his ex-husband Aaron Dingle’s marriage to Jon Sugden, his half-brother.

Despite an emotional kiss between Robert and Aaron, Aaron chose Jon, and a physical altercation with Jon led to Robert being sent back to prison after missing his parole hearing. However, as confirmed by Ryan Hawley, Robert’s return is set to be indefinite, which means that there’s much more drama in store for the Sugden family in the coming weeks.

But now, after Robert’s dramatic return, fans are starting to speculate about a new twist. Could Robert have a long-lost child living right under his nose? Fans of the show have been theorizing that Robert may have a son in the village who has been kept a secret all this time.

The Theories: Is Lewis Barton Robert’s Son?

The speculation began when a fan on an Emmerdale Facebook group proposed that Lewis Barton, played by Bradley Riches, could actually be Robert’s son. Lewis was introduced as the son of Emma Barton, played by Gillian Kearney, but some fans have suggested this might not be the full story. Could it be that Lewis is actually Robert’s son with another woman, a secret he has been hiding all these years?

One fan shared their theory, writing, “Not sure if I trust that Lewis and the timing with Robert’s return is suspicious. Could they be related?” Another fan chimed in with, “It wouldn’t be totally far-fetched if Lewis was his son or something.” The theory has gained traction, with more and more viewers joining the conversation and speculating that this DNA twist could be a major plot point.

While the official details of Robert’s past relationships remain vague, this theory has sparked a lot of excitement among Emmerdale fans. Robert’s past has already been complicated, as viewers know he has a son, Sebastian (Seb), with Rebecca White. Seb was conceived in 2017 when Robert had a brief affair with Rebecca while Aaron was in prison. However, after Rebecca and her then-boyfriend Ross Barton left the village, Seb’s storyline took a dramatic turn. In October 2024, Ross made a surprise return and revealed that Rebecca had died, and Seb was now living with her aunt in Bristol.

Could Robert Be Reunited With His Long-Lost Child?

Now that Robert has returned, fans are wondering if he will be reunited with his son, Seb. But with the theories surrounding Lewis, there could be another surprise twist in store. Could Lewis really be Robert’s son, or is this all just a coincidence? Only time will tell, but this potential family revelation has added a new layer of intrigue to Robert’s already complicated return.

The idea of Robert discovering that he has another child, especially one who has been living in the village without his knowledge, would make for a gripping storyline. And with the recent emphasis on family dynamics in Emmerdale, the idea of Robert’s long-lost son being revealed could bring an emotional and dramatic new chapter to his story.

As Robert’s return continues to unfold, fans can expect more shocking revelations, twists, and complex family interactions. Will Robert finally find the happiness he’s been searching for, or will his past mistakes continue to haunt him? The drama in Emmerdale is far from over, and the revelation of Robert’s potential new son promises to keep viewers on the edge of their seats.

Stay tuned for more updates as the mystery surrounding Robert Sugden’s family continues to unravel. The Dales are about to get a whole lot more complicated.