Emmerdale Return ‘Sealed’ for Soap Legend After Nine Years – Is Andy Sugden Back to Ruin Jacob and Sarah’s Wedding?

Emmerdale fans are buzzing with speculation as one of the village’s most iconic characters may be set for a dramatic return—just in time to shake up Jacob Gallagher and Sarah Sugden’s upcoming wedding. After nearly a decade away from the Dales, Andy Sugden could be heading back, and viewers are convinced his comeback will cause chaos.

Sarah Sugden has endured a heart-wrenching journey. From battling a life-limiting illness to bravely attempting IVF in hopes of starting a family, she’s faced one blow after another. When her ex-boyfriend Jacob offered to be her sperm donor, it seemed like a ray of hope. But that hope was shattered when Sarah was diagnosed with cancer and underwent a hysterectomy, ending her dream of carrying a child.

Heartbroken but resilient, Sarah’s grandmother Charity Dingle stepped in with a controversial idea: to act as a surrogate. The offer was meant with love, but not everyone in the family was supportive. Charity’s husband, Mackenzie, and Jacob’s grandfather Eric Pollard expressed strong reservations, adding tension to an already emotional situation.

This week, the soap took another twist. In a heartfelt attempt to lift Sarah’s spirits, Jacob planned a quiet picnic. During the intimate outing, he surprised her with a marriage proposal, confessing he wanted to be more than just a donor or friend—he wanted to be her future. Though caught off guard, Sarah said yes.

Now, with wedding bells on the horizon, longtime fans have turned their eyes toward one very specific possibility: the return of Andy Sugden, Sarah’s biological father.

On social media, speculation has reached fever pitch. A post on an Emmerdale fan group sparked a flurry of comments: “Sarah’s wedding would be the perfect opportunity for Andy to return,” one fan wrote. “He should’ve come back months ago,” another added. “This is the moment,” echoed a third.

Andy, played by Kelvin Fletcher, was a mainstay on the show from 1996 to 2016, entangled in countless dramatic arcs—from heartbreak and betrayal to violence and legal turmoil. His exit came after being falsely accused of shooting Lawrence White, forcing him to go on the run to avoid prison. He hasn’t been seen in the village since.

Bringing Andy back now would be explosive—especially given that he’s never met his daughter as an adult. His return could raise serious questions about Jacob’s role in Sarah’s life and stir up unresolved issues with the Dingle and Sugden families. With tensions already running high, Andy’s presence could push everything over the edge.

Whether he arrives as a protective father or a man haunted by past regrets, Andy’s comeback could dramatically alter Sarah’s future. And with a wedding looming, the stage is perfectly set for secrets, showdowns, and the kind of unforgettable drama Emmerdale delivers best.

Is Andy truly coming home to the Dales—or will this just be another rumour left unanswered? One thing’s for sure: if he does return, nothing will be the same again.