As Chicago Fire charges ahead with its 13th season, fans are buzzing about the possibility of a long-absent character making a return to Firehouse 51. Wendy Seager, portrayed by Andy Allo, hasn’t been seen since season 11, but showrunner Andrea Newman has sparked fresh hope by confirming that Seager’s story might not be over just yet.

In a recent interview with TVLine, Newman teased the potential return of the Office of Fire Investigation lieutenant, saying, “There’s always a chance we will see Wendy Seager, we’re a big fan of hers! You never know when the next high-level arson case will bring her around…” This brief but intriguing comment has reignited speculation about what Seager’s comeback could look like—and what it might mean for Severide and the rest of the team.

Wendy Seager was first introduced in season 8, where she immediately made an impression by trying to recruit Kelly Severide to join the OFI. Their dynamic was compelling—professional, occasionally flirtatious, and full of mutual respect. Even after Severide returned to his regular firefighting duties, the two continued to cross paths on significant investigations. She remained a recurring character in season 10 and returned briefly in season 11, but her sudden absence left viewers wondering whether the show had quietly closed the book on her.

Now, Newman’s remarks suggest otherwise. While no formal plans have been announced, the showrunner’s fondness for the character and her mention of future “high-level arson cases” indicate that the writers have not forgotten Seager’s role in the Chicago Fire universe. And with Severide’s recent time away from Firehouse 51 and his ongoing entanglement in specialized investigations, there’s a natural opening for Seager to return with a case only he can help crack.

A potential Seager return wouldn’t just be a nostalgic nod to longtime viewers—it would also provide a rich opportunity for storytelling. She brings a unique investigative skill set that complements the rest of the team’s high-octane rescue missions. A fresh OFI storyline could introduce a darker, more methodical mystery to balance the show’s fast-paced action. It could also deepen Severide’s character arc and offer meaningful interaction with the rest of the 51 crew, especially if the case forces them into dangerous territory.

Moreover, the open-ended nature of Seager’s absence leaves room for character evolution. What has she been up to since her last appearance? Has she taken on a more senior role in OFI? Could she be caught in a conflict that requires her to ask for help, not as a colleague—but as a friend? These are questions the show can explore if she returns, adding layers to her character and elevating the narrative stakes.

Ultimately, Seager’s potential return is a reminder of Chicago Fire’s strength: its ability to bring back familiar faces in ways that feel earned and exciting. Whether she shows up in season 13 or further down the line, fans can rest assured—the door is still wide open.