Soapland is buzzing with speculation as Emmerdale fans believe a long-anticipated comeback is finally in motion — Kelvin Fletcher is tipped to return as Andy Sugden, and it couldn’t come at a worse time for the show’s newest villain, John Sugden.
Kelvin Fletcher, 40, who famously portrayed Andy for two decades, may be headed back to the Dales. Although ITV has yet to confirm the news, dedicated viewers are convinced that Andy’s return is not only inevitable but will serve a powerful purpose: helping Robert Sugden expose their murderous brother, John.
🧩 A Twisted Web of Lies Unravels
John Sugden (played by Oliver Farnworth) first appeared last year, claiming to be the long-lost son of Jack Sugden. He quickly settled into the village, forging connections with his new family — including his sister Victoria — and even married Aaron Dingle in a whirlwind romance.
But behind the charming façade lies a chilling truth: John is hiding a murderous secret. In a shocking twist, it was revealed that John killed Nate Robinson last year and dumped the body in a local lake. Though John initially believed he had covered his tracks, Nate’s remains have since been discovered — and John’s desperate attempt to deflect suspicion led him to frame Nate’s widow, Tracy.
Now, the cracks are beginning to show.
🔍 Robert Returns… and He’s Not Alone for Long
Robert Sugden (Ryan Hawley) has also made a sensational return to the village after a six-year absence. Released from prison, he’s now living with his sister Victoria and is determined to rebuild his life — but his instincts tell him that something about John just doesn’t add up.
Viewers have seen Robert begin to dig into John’s past while also trying to reignite his relationship with Aaron. But if Robert is going to unearth the truth and bring justice for Nate, he’ll need help. Enter: Andy Sugden.
👀 A Family Showdown Brewing
Fans have taken to social media to voice their theories. “If Andy Sugden did come back, whose side would he be on? Robert’s or John’s?” one user asked. “They were never exactly close, but Andy has a strong moral compass.”
Another added: “I really think Andy would be team Rob. Especially if it came down to protecting someone. Would love to see this play out — Ryan and Kelvin had amazing chemistry.”
Andy’s 2016 departure was dramatic — fleeing the village with a fake passport after Robert helped him escape a dangerous situation. His absence has left a void, but his return now could be game-changing.
📺 Don’t Miss What Happens Next
With Robert gathering evidence, Aaron watching from the shadows, and John’s lies beginning to collapse — the return of Andy Sugden could be the final nail in the coffin for John.
Will Andy choose loyalty, justice, or revenge?
