Emmerdale fans have been left questioning the death of Anthony Fox, with many speculating that the character may not actually be dead after all. The revelation of Anthony’s murder back in January shocked viewers, but recent developments have left fans wondering if there’s more to the story than initially thought.

In a dramatic turn of events, Aaron Dingle (Danny Miller) was initially tormented by the belief that he had killed Anthony during a violent confrontation. After the altercation, Aaron later discovered Anthony’s body at the depot, leading him to desperately plead with his partner, John Sugden (Oliver Farnworth), to dispose of the corpse. However, as the storyline unfolded, it was revealed that Ruby Fox-Milligan (Louisa Lytton) was the true perpetrator of the crime, having murdered her abusive father after years of torment.

A flashback revealed the horrifying truth about Anthony’s past, including his sexual abuse of Ruby as a teenager, which eventually led to the shocking discovery that Anthony was the biological father of Ruby’s daughter, Steph. Ruby’s decision to kill her father was a long-buried secret, one that she had carried for over three decades before confiding in her partner Caleb and his siblings, Chas and Cain.

As the story continued, John was reluctant to reveal the location of Anthony’s body to Aaron, fearing it would make their situation even worse. Eventually, under pressure, John confessed that he had buried Anthony in a makeshift grave in the woods. This revelation led to a secret meeting between John and the Dingles, where John explained that the success of their plan depended on everyone sticking to it. The pressure of the situation weighed heavily on Ruby, who was seen visiting her father’s grave and breaking down under the weight of her actions.

However, despite the apparent closure, fans on social media have begun to speculate that Anthony’s body may not be where John claimed it was buried. On Reddit and various Emmerdale fan pages, viewers have voiced their doubts about the legitimacy of Anthony’s death, suggesting that John might be hiding something. One fan commented, “I don’t think that’s where Anthony is buried; I can bet that if they dug up his grave, the body wouldn’t be there,” while another agreed, saying, “Totally agree that Anthony isn’t buried there.”

The growing fan theories are fueled by the idea that John, who has been a suspicious character since his arrival in the Dales in August 2024, might be concealing a major secret. Could he be secretly keeping Anthony alive somewhere, nursing him back to health in an attempt to use him for some unknown purpose? This theory has sparked a new wave of intrigue among fans, as they try to piece together the mystery of Anthony’s fate.

Could it be that John has been secretly hiding Anthony in the village, and if so, what is his endgame? The idea of Anthony being alive and in hiding opens up numerous possibilities for future storylines, as fans speculate about what John’s true motives could be. Is he protecting Anthony for a particular reason, or is there something more sinister at play?

While the official storyline has suggested that Anthony is dead and buried, the possibility that John might be keeping him hidden adds another layer of complexity to the already intense drama. As the Dingles and Ruby continue to grapple with the consequences of their actions, viewers are left on edge, wondering if the truth about Anthony’s death will ever fully be revealed.

This twist also raises the question of whether Ruby’s dark secret will come to light once again, especially with John’s growing presence in the Dales. With Emmerdale known for its shocking plot twists and unexpected revelations, the mystery surrounding Anthony Fox’s death may not be as straightforward as it seems.

As fans eagerly await more developments, the theories about Anthony’s survival and John’s possible involvement continue to swirl. Will the truth eventually come to light, or will this storyline remain shrouded in mystery? One thing is certain: Emmerdale fans will be keeping a close eye on the twists and turns to come.