Emmerdale Fans Question Whether Anthony Fox is Really Dead After Shocking Twist

Emmerdale fans are in a frenzy after recent episodes left them questioning the fate of Anthony Fox, with many convinced that his death may not be as final as originally thought. After John Sugden (played by Oliver Farnworth) disposed of Anthony’s body, it seemed that the storyline had come to a close. However, viewers are now speculating that Anthony may still be alive and could have a major role to play in the drama to come.

Anthony, who had a tumultuous history with his daughter Ruby Fox-Miligan (Beth Cordingly), was revealed to be the villain responsible for several dark secrets, including the sexual assault of Ruby in her teenage years. After being violently attacked by Aaron Dingle (Danny Miller) and then later suffocated by Ruby, Anthony’s supposed death was covered up by John, who hid the body.

Emmerdale spoilers: Robert’s revenge after John’s win – what needs to ...

But now, fans are starting to doubt whether the villain is truly dead. A Reddit user wrote, “Do we think Anthony’s body is really gone? Or has John kept him hidden somewhere?” Another fan added, “I can’t shake the feeling that he’s not really dead and that John’s just pretending.”

The theory comes after John used Anthony’s death as leverage against Caleb Miligan (Will Ash), forcing him to take extreme actions. Viewers suspect that John could use the supposed death of Anthony as a bargaining chip, continuing to manipulate situations to his advantage.

Although John claims to have buried Anthony in the woods, some fans are questioning his motives and wondering if there’s more to the story than he’s letting on. Many believe that John could be holding onto this secret for future use, potentially as blackmail material against other characters, such as Aaron and Robert Sugden (Ryan Hawley).

Emmerdale fans 'work out' John Sugden's true identity after Anthony Fox ...

Despite some fans’ suspicions, it’s also important to remember that Anthony was said to have terminal cancer, which adds another layer of complexity to the theory. Could the cancer have been a lie, or could John be manipulating the situation further?

As the storyline unfolds, Emmerdale viewers are eagerly awaiting answers. Will the truth about Anthony’s fate finally come to light, or will John continue to control the situation, with devastating consequences for those around him? Stay tuned for more updates!

Related articles

John Palmer Alone — Is He Coping Without Irene? | Home & Away Spoilers (Airs 8 Oct 2025)

Home & Away spoilers for Wednesday, October 8, 2025, reveal a deeply emotional turn as John Palmer is forced to face life in Summer Bay without his longtime…

😱Home and Away SPOILERS — BREE STABBED! Shocking Hospital Attack (Oct 10, 2025)

 Home and Away SPOILERS — BREE STABBED! Shocking Hospital Attack (Oct 10, 2025) Home and Away fans are bracing for one of the most shocking and heartbreaking episodes…

Home and Away Star Matt Evans Reveals the Exit He Originally Wanted for Theo Poulos

A Tragic Farewell in Summer Bay It’s been an emotional week for Home and Away fans as Theo Poulos met a heartbreaking end in scenes that stunned Australian viewers….

TRAGIC HERO! Theo’s Final Act in Home and Away Stuns Summer Bay

From Troubled Teen to Beloved Hero Theo Poulos’s time in Home and Away has been a journey filled with heartbreak, redemption, and courage. Introduced as Leah’s reckless nephew, Theo’s…

HOT NEWS!! Emmerdale fans ‘work out’ when John Sugden wiII finaIIy be exposed and it’s soon

Emmerdale Fans Convinced John Sugden’s Dark Secrets Will Be Exposed — And the Clock Is Ticking When it comes to shocking storylines, Emmerdale has never shied away from pushing…

HOT NEWS!! Charity’s abortion decision confirmed in Emmerdale as Sarah heads for crushing heartbreak

Charity Dingle (Emma Atkins) gets the catastrophic news she feared – that the baby she’s carrying is Ross Barton’s (Michael Parr) and she decides on extreme measures…