There were many reasons behind Costner’s Yellowstone exit, with one relating to the show’s schedule. Filming the neo-Western drama took a long time, and Costner wanted to condense production on the Paramount Network series to focus more on the Horizon: An American Saga movies. Ultimately, the two parties weren’t able to come to an agreement. Costner left Yellowstone, devoting most of his time to his epic Western film franchise, while Sheridan and co. were forced to end the TV show without their lead character.
Why John Dutton’s Yellowstone Fate Caused A Backlash
Kevin Costner’s Character Was Murdered
During the Yellowstone season 5, part 2 premiere, viewers learned that John supposedly died by suicide in the middle of the night at the Governor’s mansion. However, Beth and Jamie were hesitant to believe that story, and their intuition was right. Sarah Atwood hired assassins to murder John and make it look like a suicide. In later episodes, Jamie proved his father was killed, and the Duttons (and the ranch hands, Chief Thomas Rainwater, and Lynelle Perry) buried him in their family’s graveyard, next to his ancestors and son. Unfortunately, many were unhappy with this ending for John.
Some viewers were upset about how abruptly Yellowstone killed off John. After being the face of the series since the beginning, they thought Kevin Costner’s character deserved a better sendoff. Given John’s legacy in Yellowstone, viewers felt disappointed that his (and the show’s) ending was so anticlimactic, wishing that his death was more grand or impactful, instead of just being the catalyst to the other characters’ central dilemma of losing the ranch. Unfortunately, there’s no going back for Yellowstone. However, there is a way for Costner to move forward.
Horizon: Part 2 (& Beyond) Can Be The Complete Western Story Costner Didn’t Get With Yellowstone
The Horizon Film Series Is Set To Have 4 Parts
Horizon: An American Saga is all the more exciting and promising because not only is it a Western saga that Costner is directing and co-writing, but he is also playing the lead, Hayes Ellison. So, Costner has complete control over the franchise’s story and his character’s full journey, including his ending. He can make it much more satisfying than John Dutton’s conclusion. Unfortunately, bringing Horizon: An American Saga full circle with a fourth movie might not be possible as the film series’ fate is up in the air.
The Biggest Obstacle To Horizon Is Its Release – And It’s Getting Closer To Overcoming It
Chapter 1 Was A Box Office Failure
Horizon: An American Saga – Chapter 1 was released on June 28, 2024, and ultimately bombed at the box office. The movie only grossed $38.7 million against a $50 million budget ($38 million of which Kevin Costner personally funded, per Variety). Chapter 1 also received mixed reviews from critics. Consequently, Chapter 2‘s premiere was delayed.
Horizon: An American Saga – Chapter 2‘s theatrical release might be right around the corner, giving fans the chance to form their opinions and open the door for the development of Chapter 3 and Chapter 4.
However, the tides might be turning for Costner. The sequel made its debut at the 81st Venice International Film Festival on September 7, 2024, and is set to be screened at the Santa Barbara International Film Festival on February 7, 2025. Horizon: An American Saga – Chapter 2‘s theatrical release might be right around the corner, giving fans the chance to form their opinions and open the door for the development of Chapter 3 and Chapter 4.
