In a season filled with danger, death, and unyielding tension, the finale of 1923 brought an unexpected twist that left fans crying out for more. Spencer and Alex, after facing countless trials, finally seem on the verge of reaching Montana—only to be separated in the most devastating way possible.

Throughout the season, the pair navigated perilous obstacles, from Spencer’s violent confrontations to Alex’s strained ties with her past. Their reunion on the ship was meant to signify a new chapter, but fate had other plans.

The finale not only sees them torn apart physically but emotionally, as Alex’s past comes back to haunt her. Her ex-fiancé Arthur (Rafe Soule) challenges Spencer to a duel, leading to a brutal encounter on the ship’s deck. Despite Spencer’s clear warnings and reluctance, the duel escalates when Arthur breaks the rules and pulls a gun on him. In a moment of raw survival, Spencer throws Arthur overboard, but the damage is done—Arthur’s family demands Spencer’s arrest, and Alex is confined to her room.

In a desperate bid to escape, Alex manages to flee, but by the time she reaches Spencer, he is being taken away in handcuffs. Their final moments together are gut-wrenching—exchanging “I love yous” with tears in their eyes, knowing they’re about to be separated once again. Their love, so intense and pure, is now held at arm’s length by forces beyond their control. The final scene cuts to a heartbreaking close, leaving fans on edge for what comes next.

A Massive Shift Ahead in Season 2

Brandon Sklenar, who portrays Spencer, revealed to TV Insider just how gut-wrenching the scene was to film. He described the finale as one of the most emotional moments of the season, with both him and Julia Schlaepfer (Alex) moved to tears by their characters’ separation. “To finally hear them say ‘I love you’ and then have that ripped away—it’s brutal,” Sklenar said. It’s clear from his comments that the intensity of their romance will continue to fuel the tension heading into 1923‘s second season.

As we look ahead to Season 2, fans can expect even darker twists as Spencer and Alex face seemingly insurmountable obstacles. The finale sets up a significant shift in the tone of the series, and Sklenar hints at even more emotional rollercoasters in the future. “It’s going to be a massive shift in the tone of the show,” he teased.

What’s Next for Spencer and Alex?

While the end of 1923’s first season might seem like a tragic conclusion, it’s clear that Spencer and Alex’s story is far from over. Their love will be tested by distance, deception, and the ghosts of their pasts. As Alex is left behind in a tearful goodbye, the possibility of a reunion remains uncertain, but one thing is for sure—their emotional connection will continue to haunt both characters, and viewers, long after the credits roll.

Stay tuned as 1923 prepares to unravel even deeper secrets and explore the consequences of Spencer and Alex’s heartbreaking separation. The stage is set for explosive revelations, and as the clock ticks towards Season 2, fans are left wondering if these two will ever find their way back to each other—or if they’ll be torn apart forever.