The expansive world of Yellowstone has long captivated audiences with its intricate storytelling and rich character development. Yet, in April 2024, the franchise faced a real-life tragedy that resonated deeply with fans and the Native American community alike: the sudden and untimely death of actor Cole Brings Plenty, known for his role as Pete Plenty Clouds in the prequel series 1923.
A Promising Talent Silenced Too Soon
At just 27 years old, Cole Brings Plenty was emerging as a compelling presence in the Western genre. His portrayal of Pete Plenty Clouds, a compassionate sheepherder who aids Teonna Rainwater (played by Aminah Nieves) in her escape from an oppressive boarding school, showcased his depth and commitment to authentic storytelling. Beyond 1923, Brings Plenty’s credits included appearances in The Tall Tales of Jim Bridger and Into the Wild Frontier, signaling a burgeoning career rooted in narratives that honored his heritage.(SlashFilm, Decider)
The Disappearance and Discovery
On March 31, 2024, Brings Plenty was last seen in Lawrence, Kansas. Reports emerged of a domestic disturbance involving a woman screaming for help; by the time authorities arrived, the suspect had fled. Brings Plenty was subsequently named a suspect in the incident, with traffic cameras capturing his vehicle leaving the city. His family reported him missing on April 2, expressing concern over his uncharacteristic absence and missed appointments.(The Daily Beast, BBC, People.com)
Tragically, on April 5, deputies discovered Brings Plenty’s body in a wooded area near an unoccupied vehicle in Johnson County, Kansas. The Johnson County Sheriff’s Office stated there was “no indication of foul play” in his death. However, the exact cause of death remains undisclosed, with court documents sealed to respect the family’s privacy.(Kansas City, New York Post, The Cinemaholic)
Community Outcry and Calls for Transparency
Brings Plenty’s death sparked a wave of grief and demands for clarity within the Native American community. The Cheyenne River Sioux Tribe called for a “full and thorough investigation” into his disappearance and subsequent death. His father, Joe Brings Plenty Sr., voiced frustration over the lack of information, stating, “We want a full investigation done, a fair investigation, to find out what happened with Cole.”(The Daily Beast, Decider, The Cinemaholic)
Critics also questioned the initial handling of the case by law enforcement, suggesting that Brings Plenty was treated more as a fugitive than a missing person in potential crisis. Lawrence Police Chief Rich Lockhart acknowledged the tragedy and emphasized the need to build trust with Native American community members.(The Daily Beast, New York Post)
A Heartfelt Tribute in 1923
In honor of Brings Plenty’s contribution to 1923, the show’s second season premiere featured a poignant tribute. The episode opened with a sepia-toned montage of his scenes, culminating in the message, “In memoriam Cole Brings Plenty.” The role of Pete Plenty Clouds has since been recast with Jeremy Gauna, ensuring the character’s journey continues, albeit under a new portrayal.(EW.com)
Legacy and Reflection
Cole Brings Plenty’s passing is a somber reminder of the fragility of life and the importance of mental health awareness, especially within communities that often face systemic challenges. His dedication to portraying authentic Indigenous narratives left an indelible mark on the Yellowstone franchise and its audience.(New York Post)
As the series progresses, fans and creators alike carry forward Brings Plenty’s legacy, honoring his memory through continued storytelling that reflects the resilience and richness of Native American cultures.
If you or someone you know is experiencing domestic abuse, support is available. In the U.S., contact the National Domestic Violence Hotline at 800-799-7233 or text START to 88788.(Decider)
