A fleeting love hidden behind fire and badge…
Long before their careers diverged and headlines turned elsewhere, a short-lived flame is said to have sparked between Chicago Fire’s Taylor Kinney and Chicago P.D.’s Sophia Bush. Though unconfirmed, this quiet whirlwind romance left behind more than just whispers — it left fans wondering what could have been.

Behind the Scenes of One Chicago: A Love Almost Forgotten

Back in 2014, the One Chicago universe was just starting to expand. Chicago Fire was in full swing, Chicago P.D. had launched, and the chemistry among cast members was electric — on screen and, as rumors suggest, off it too.

Amid the chaos of crossovers and intense storylines, a spark reportedly ignited between Taylor Kinney, best known as the brooding firefighter Kelly Severide, and Sophia Bush, the sharp and fearless detective Erin Lindsay. Though neither actor has ever confirmed the romance publicly, production insiders from the era have spoken quietly of the pair’s closeness, describing their interactions as “more than just friendly.”

Their connection, according to sources, played out quietly over a few months between late 2014 and early 2015. At the time, Sophia Bush had recently ended a relationship, and Kinney was just beginning to step into the spotlight with his soon-to-be-famous romance with pop star Lady Gaga.

A Blink-and-You-Miss-It Romance

This brief relationship, often dubbed by fans as the “quiet whirlwind romance,” came and went without tabloid fanfare or social media hints. There were no red carpet appearances, no photoshoots, not even a cryptic Instagram post — just subtle glances and on-set moments that co-stars reportedly picked up on.

But then, just as quickly as it began, it ended.

According to those familiar with the situation, the relationship ended amicably. Neither party spoke publicly about it, and they were never photographed together outside of production. Since Bush’s exit from Chicago P.D. and Kinney’s continued run on Chicago Fire, they haven’t been seen together in public again.

The Legacy of a Private Flame

Yet in true One Chicago fashion, fans never forget. The chemistry that may have briefly sparked between Bush and Kinney still fuels speculation on forums and fan pages today. It’s not just about gossip — it’s about the magic of storytelling. In a universe built on camaraderie, loyalty, and heart-stopping action, even the off-screen relationships become part of the lore.

Sophia Bush has since pursued new projects, advocacy work, and relationships, while Taylor Kinney continues to lead Chicago Fire as one of its most beloved figures. But for longtime fans, this rumored connection is more than a footnote — it’s a secret chapter that adds even more depth to the One Chicago saga.

As we look ahead to Chicago Fire Season 14, with Severide and Kidd preparing for parenthood and new leadership dynamics shaking Firehouse 51, it’s little whispers like these — quiet, unconfirmed, but unforgettable — that remind us why fans remain so loyal to the show and its stars.

One fire may have been extinguished, but its smoke still lingers in the Windy City.