In the harsh wilderness of Montana and the unforgiving legacy of the Dutton ranch, there’s one thing fans can agree on: the cowboys of Yellowstone, 1883, and 1923 aren’t just rugged—they’re red-hot. Whether they’re taming horses or breaking hearts, these men have captured our imaginations and fueled countless daydreams.

So who’s the hottest of them all? We’ve ranked the 14 most irresistible cowboys across the entire Yellowstone universe. Some are battle-hardened antiheroes. Others are soulful romantics. And every single one of them? Unforgettable.

14. Wes Bentley as Jamie Dutton
Controversial and complex, Jamie Dutton’s tortured soul and icy stare make him the ultimate tragic heartthrob. Wes Bentley plays him with haunted vulnerability—beautiful, broken, and boiling over with secrets.

13. Jefferson White as Jimmy Hurdstrom
From bungling thief to hardened cowboy, Jimmy’s transformation is pure gold. His underdog charm, goofy heart, and painful growth make him impossible not to root for—and yes, lowkey hot.

12. Denim Richards as Colby
With sarcasm sharp enough to cut barbed wire and a loyalty that runs deep, Colby brings brains and brawn. Denim Richards nails the cowboy-next-door energy, and fans love his sly swagger.

11. Forrie J. Smith as Lloyd Pierce
The bunkhouse veteran with a weathered face and silver hair that screams “don’t mess with me.” Lloyd isn’t just tough—he’s wise, wounded, and lowkey seductive. Cowboy grit never looked so good.

10. LaMonica Garrett as Thomas (1883)
Calm, calculated, and committed, Thomas is the rock everyone leans on. LaMonica Garrett’s performance exudes strength and stoicism—a quiet power that commands attention and admiration.

9. Harrison Ford as Jacob Dutton (1923)
He’s grizzled, commanding, and carrying the weight of a generation. Harrison Ford’s Jacob Dutton is more than an aging patriarch—he’s a living legend. Charisma doesn’t fade. It evolves.

8. Sam Elliott as Shea Brennan (1883)
With that gravel voice and haunted stare, Shea is cowboy nobility. Sam Elliott’s performance is pure gravitas—every scar tells a story. Wounded and wise, he rides into your heart and never leaves.

7. Tim McGraw as James Dutton (1883)
The original Dutton dream. Tim McGraw brings authenticity and raw masculinity to the role of James. He’s tough but tender, leading his family with quiet desperation—and serious cowboy cred.

6. Ryan Bingham as Walker
A guitar-slinging outlaw with a poet’s soul, Walker is trouble—and temptation. Ryan Bingham’s real-life cowboy roots and brooding presence make him the bunkhouse’s ultimate wildcard.

5. Brandon Sklenar as Spencer Dutton (1923)
Wounded, romantic, and deadly in a fight—Spencer is pure chaos wrapped in charm. Brandon Sklenar’s performance is emotionally raw, and his looks? Let’s just say fans felt every smirk and scar.

4. Ian Bohen as Ryan
Ryan is the sarcastic sweetheart of the bunkhouse—less rage, more mischief. Ian Bohen plays him with easy charisma and charm that sneaks up on you. He doesn’t need to yell. One smile is enough.

3. Kevin Costner as John Dutton
He’s the godfather of Yellowstone, and his power is undeniable. Kevin Costner brings gravitas, grit, and old-school sex appeal. Stoic, strong, and impossible to ignore—John Dutton is the West.

2. Luke Grimes as Kayce Dutton
Haunted soldier. Loving father. Reluctant heir. Kayce is a storm of intensity, and Luke Grimes brings it all with aching vulnerability. His every glance says more than words—and yes, it’s hot.

1. Cole Hauser as Rip Wheeler
Who else could it be? Rip Wheeler is the cowboy fantasy. Fierce, loyal, violent when needed, and deeply devoted to Beth—he bleeds for the brand and loves with abandon. Cole Hauser’s Rip is the reason millions fell for Yellowstone. Whether he’s fighting in the mud or whispering “I love you” under a starlit sky, he commands the screen—and our hearts.

From the ranch to the battlefield, from love stories to blood feuds, the cowboys of the Yellowstone universe remind us why we still crave the myth of the Wild West. They’re flawed. They’re loyal. And they’re absolutely unforgettable.

So now the question is…
Who’s your number one? Did we miss someone, or did Rip truly reign supreme?